Most technical learning programs live or die on the strength of the SME relationship. Yet we train learning professionals in design models and authoring tools, and almost never in the human skills that the partnership actually demands.
Ask anyone in this profession about their hardest project and, more often than not, the story is not about the content, the platform or the deadline. It is about the expert they worked with. The engineer who can explain a hydraulic system in their sleep but goes quiet when asked why it matters to a new starter. The compliance manager who wants every clause of the legislation included in the module, word for word. The operations lead who is brilliant, generous and completely unavailable for the next six weeks.
Subject matter experts are the beating heart of good capability development. They are also part of one of the trickiest professional relationships we manage. Not because they are difficult people, but because we are asking them to do something genuinely hard: hand over knowledge they have spent a career building, then trust us to reshape parts of it into a short course.
Here is my honest view. After years of working in L&D and partnering with subject matter experts across compliance, technical and specialist domains, I can confidently make this statement. The mechanics of learning design can be taught. We can learn instructional models, adult learning principles, technology, AI and design techniques through study, mentoring and experience. But, what is far more difficult (but possible) to develop is the emotional intelligence needed to work effectively with experts. It takes humility to recognise the depth of another person’s expertise, curiosity to ask thoughtful questions, empathy to understand their perspective, and judgement to build trust while translating complex knowledge into learning that others can understand.
These capabilities are less visible than learning design frameworks, yet they often determine whether a learning solution truly succeeds. In my view, they deserve far greater attention within our profession.
A filing cabinet or a partner?
Too often, SMEs are treated as little more than a source of content. Learning Designers book an hour, extract what they need and disappear to build the thing. Then return with a storyboard and wonder why it comes back covered in red ink or overflowing with overlapping Microsoft Word comments.
Consider what is actually happening in that moment. For most experts, their knowledge is not just information. It is connected to their identity, reputation and, often, a personal sense of responsibility for keeping people safe or the business compliant. When we cut, simplify or restructure their material, it can land as a judgement that their knowledge does not matter. Of course they push back. We would too.
The move that changes everything is treating the SME as a design partner rather than an information vending machine. Their accountability is accuracy and depth. Ours is relevance and learning. When both parties understand their roles, the friction drops dramatically. But establishing those roles takes deliberate relationship work, and that is where emotional intelligence earns its keep.
Name the real challenges
Pretending the friction points do not exist helps nobody, so let us name them.
The first is the curse of knowledge. Experts genuinely cannot remember what it was like not to know. They skip steps that feel obvious to them but are invisible to everyone else. This is not arrogance; it is cognitive. The practitioner’s role is to be professionally naïve and ask the questions a novice would ask.
“What would go wrong if someone missed that step?” remains one of the most powerful questions in learning design.
The second challenge is that, to an expert, everything is essential. Ask an SME what learners need to know and the answer is usually “all of it”, because depth feels like quality. The discipline is to keep returning to the learner and the task. Not, “Is this true?” but, “Does the learner need this to perform the job safely and effectively on day one, or to complete this specific task?”
Those are very different questions, and only one of them builds a usable program.
The third challenge deserves to be called out properly because it sits underneath many of the others: time poverty and the pressure nobody sees. Supporting a learning program rarely appears in an SME’s KPIs, performance review or bonus. Every hour they give us is carved out of operational targets, client deadlines, audits, incidents and the needs of their team.
The very thing that makes them the SME, being exceptionally good at what they do, is also what makes them the person everyone else in the business is queuing to see. In many learning projects, the availability of the subject matter expert becomes the primary constraint on progress.
So, when an SME cancels twice, replies at 10 pm or arrives distracted and half-prepared, that is rarely disinterest. It is often a person being pulled in six directions who agreed to help on top of everything else.
The worst thing we can do is treat their scarcity as a character flaw. The better response is to design around it and recognise that SME time is a resourcing decision that belongs with leadership, not on the shoulders of an expert quietly drowning in goodwill. For HR and L&D leaders, this is the sponsorship conversation to have before the project starts, not after it stalls.
Where emotional intelligence does the heavy lifting
The challenges may be structural, but navigating them is fundamentally human. Each one calls on a different aspect of emotional intelligence.
Self-awareness comes first. Notice your own reaction when an SME challenges your design. That defensive flare is worth acknowledging privately and setting aside because the expert is usually not attacking your competence. They are protecting something that matters to them.
Empathy transforms the extraction process. When an SME rambles, resists simplification or clings to jargon, curiosity serves us better than frustration. What are they worried about? Often, it is risk.
“If we do not include this and something goes wrong, that is on me.”
Once you hear the fear underneath the friction, you can address the real concern. Sometimes, a single line in a facilitator guide or a link to the full procedure is all it takes for an expert to release their grip on the detail.
Relationship management is built through small, compounding moments. Send questions before the session, not during it. Play back what you heard in plain language before you build anything. Show experts how their input shaped the product, not merely that you collected it.
And give credit loudly. Name your SMEs in the program, thank them in front of the Senior Leadership Team and tell them directly which of their stories resonated most strongly in the pilot. Experts who feel valued come back. Experts who feel mined do not.
Finally, social awareness means adapting to the human in front of you. Some SMEs want structure and a tightly organised question list. Others need to talk through stories and tangents before the gold appears. Neither approach is wrong. Adjusting your style to suit the person is not simply a soft skill. It is the skill.
Practical disciplines that change the dynamic
In our Nexperk projects, every SME participates in an onboarding session before contributing and a formal sign-off at the conclusion of the project. During onboarding, we begin building the relationship, explain the review process, clarify roles and expectations, and outline the approval requirements for each review stage.
Investing this time upfront creates shared accountability, reduces ambiguity and significantly improves the quality and timeliness of feedback. Here are a handful of practices that consistently move the SME relationship from strained to collaborative.
- Start with the learner, together
Before asking a single content question, spend ten minutes building a shared picture of the learner: who they are, the pressures they face and what they commonly get wrong. When the SME can see the learner clearly, they begin editing themselves. The learner becomes the reason content is cut, rather than the designer.
- Draft questions that draw out stories, not just facts
“Tell me about a time this went badly” yields richer material than “Walk me through the procedure”. Stories carry context, consequence and emotion, and they are often where the real performance gaps are hiding. Questions that earn their keep include:
“What do new starters always get wrong in their first month?”
“What does the best person you have seen do differently?”
“If you had only five minutes to teach this, what would you say?”
Well-drafted questions do much of the hardest work for you.
- Give depth a visible home
Experts release detail far more readily when it is rehomed rather than deleted. A resource hub, stretch module or linked procedure library turns “You cut my content” into “You organised my content”.
- Agree the review rules upfront
Before any draft circulates, establish what feedback is needed. Technical accuracy and factual completeness belong with the SME. Decisions about learning strategy, tone, structure, interactions and instructional design remain the responsibility of the learning designer.
Wherever possible, review together, live. Written feedback strips away tone and leaves room for assumptions on both sides. A 30-minute walkthrough can resolve issues in real time that might otherwise take three rounds of tracked changes to untangle. It not only speeds up the review process but also helps preserve the relationship.
The AI elephant in the room
No honest article about SME collaboration in 2026 can skip this. A growing number of learning designers are now working AI-first: generating a draft module, storyboard or question bank with a large language model, then bringing it to the SME for verification rather than beginning with a blank page.
Used well, this is a genuine gift to the time-poverty problem. The SME’s scarcest resource is attention, and reviewing a solid draft takes a fraction of the time that authoring from scratch demands.
AI can also complete the unglamorous preparation that makes SME sessions sharper: summarising source procedures, drafting interview questions and surfacing the obvious content so the precious human hour can be spent on the nuances, stories and judgement calls that only the expert can provide.
In my own practice, AI has quietly moved the SME conversation up the value chain. We spend less time asking, “What are the steps?” and more time exploring, “Where does this go wrong, and why?”
But the emotional intelligence stakes have increased, not diminished.
Think about what an AI-first draft can signal to an expert if it is handled clumsily: A machine wrote your job. Please check it.
For someone whose knowledge is closely connected to their identity and professional standing, that can land hard. Some resistance to AI-drafted content is really resistance to being made to feel replaceable. The practitioner who cannot read that subtext will burn trust at speed.
There is also a risk that deserves to be stated plainly. Large language models can produce fluent, confident content that is subtly wrong, as well as generic content that was never true of your organisation in the first place. In compliance, safety and technical domains, a hallucinated step or an American regulatory reference is not an inconvenience; it is a liability.
This means the SME’s role has not diminished. It has changed from author to authority. Verification is now one of the most valuable contributions they make, and it needs to be positioned accordingly.
Over the past three years of working with AI, I have learnt several principles for keeping the AI and SME partnership healthy. The truth is, I learnt many of them the hard way.
First, be transparent. If AI helped draft the material, say so. Experts who discover it later may feel deceived, and that is an entirely avoidable breach of trust.
Second, position the AI draft for what it is: raw ai produced material designed to accelerate the process, not a finished product awaiting a rubber stamp. Make it clear that the draft exists to preserve their time for the thinking, judgement and experience that only they can bring. It's worth noting, that you can offer them to produce draft materials without ai if that is a preference.
Third, never allow an AI-generated draft to reach learners without genuine expert verification. Build that sign-off formally into your process so it becomes visible and valued work rather than an invisible favour.
Finally, keep asking for the stories. AI can generate a procedure, but it cannot tell you about the afternoon on site when that procedure failed, what happened next, how the team responded or what they learnt from it.
Those stories carry the judgement, context and lived experience that transform information into capability. They remain, and will continue to remain, the gold that only your experts hold.
The bottom line
Working with SMEs is a relationship, and relationships run on trust, not templates. The practitioners who do this well are not necessarily the ones with the slickest storyboards or digital courses. They are the ones who make experts feel respected, understood and safe enough to hand over what they know.
For a profession that talks constantly about human-centred design, it is time we applied the same principle to the humans we design with.
Bring your curiosity. Bring your patience. And bring your emotional intelligence because, on the hard days, it is the only tool in the kit that truly matters.
Vanessa Trower is the Founder and Principal Consultant of Nexperk, a Sydney-based people and performance partner for large frontline workforces. She hosts The Transformation Edit and SHIFT Happens on the Front Line podcasts. Want to talk about what this could look like in your organisation? Book a chat with Nexperk.