Why Cohorts Still Have a Place in an Age of Learning on Demand

Sometimes the people learning beside us are as important as the content itself

Over the past decade, workplace learning has become increasingly individualised. Employees can access an online course when they need it, watch a short video between meetings, search for an answer in the moment, or now ask AI to explain a concept almost instantly. From an accessibility perspective, this is an extraordinary step forward. Learning can be faster, more personalised and available at the point of need.

Yet I think there is something we need to be careful not to lose as we make learning increasingly convenient: other people.

Some of the most meaningful learning I have seen has happened within cohorts, where a group of people moves through a development experience together over time. The formal content is important, of course, but so is what happens around it. Someone shares an example from their part of the business and another participant suddenly understands the concept differently. A learner discovers that someone else is struggling with exactly the same leadership challenge. A conversation continues after the workshop because two people want to test an idea together.

These interactions can look incidental when we design a program, but they are often where learning starts to take on greater meaning. There is also good reason, from what we understand about how people learn, to design deliberately for these interactions rather than hoping they happen.

A cohort is therefore more than a convenient way of putting 15 or 20 people through the same program at the same time. Designed well, the cohort becomes part of the learning architecture itself.

Learning rarely happens in isolation

One of the limitations of thinking about learning primarily as content is that it can lead us to design for the individual while overlooking the social environment in which capability actually develops.

At work, we rarely perform in isolation. We solve problems with other people, observe how colleagues approach situations, ask questions, compare judgement, seek advice and learn through conversations that may never appear on a learning plan. This is particularly relevant when the capability being developed does not have one perfectly correct answer.

Consider leadership development. We can teach someone a feedback framework, but knowing the steps of a framework is very different from deciding how to approach a conversation with an employee who has lost confidence. We can teach change models, but applying them when a team is tired of another transformation requires judgement. We can explain stakeholder management, but navigating competing priorities and relationships is learned partly through experience.

A cohort gives people somewhere to explore that complexity. Rather than simply asking, “Do I understand the model?”, learners begin asking, “How would you handle this?”, “Does this happen in your team as well?” and “What did you try when you faced something similar?”

The learning moves beyond understanding a concept and into interpreting how that concept works in the reality of organisational life.

What the science of learning tells us

The more we understand about learning and the brain, the harder it becomes to think of learning as simply transferring information from one person or system to another.

Learning requires attention, the processing of new information, connection with what we already know, retrieval, practice and reinforcement over time. Memory is not strengthened simply because someone has been exposed to information once. Learners need opportunities to revisit ideas, retrieve them, apply them in different contexts and make meaningful connections.

This is one reason spacing and retrieval are so useful in learning design. A cohort program that unfolds over time can create repeated opportunities for learners to encounter an idea, leave the learning environment, attempt to use it at work and then return to retrieve, discuss and reconsider what they have learned. The time between sessions is not necessarily empty space in the program. When it is designed intentionally, it can become an active part of the learning process.

Social interaction adds another dimension. When learners have to explain an idea in their own words, respond to another person's interpretation, work through a problem together or connect a concept to an experience, they are doing considerably more cognitive work than simply listening to an explanation.

The emotional environment also influences the experience of learning. If someone is preoccupied with embarrassment, worried about being judged for asking a question or reluctant to admit they do not understand something, their attention is divided between engaging with the learning and managing how they are perceived by the group. This is where the quality of the cohort becomes important. As people become more comfortable with one another, questioning, experimentation and reflection can become easier.

I am also cautious about using neuroscience as a fashionable label for learning design. We do not need to attach a brain scan to every learning principle to make it credible. What research into memory, cognition and learning does give us is a useful foundation for thinking about attention, retrieval, spacing, practice and the active processing of information.

Ultimately, learning requires the learner to do something with what they encounter. Consuming content is only one part of that process.

The cohort creates another source of expertise

There can sometimes be an assumption in learning design that expertise sits primarily with the facilitator or within the learning content. In workplace learning, that is rarely the whole story because the people participating bring years of professional and personal experience into the room with them.

One participant may have worked through a difficult organisational change. Someone else may have developed an effective way of coaching their team. Another may understand a customer group, operational process or part of the organisation that others have never encountered.

When a cohort is facilitated well, that experience becomes available to everyone.

This does not diminish the role of the facilitator. If anything, it makes facilitation more sophisticated. The role extends beyond transmitting knowledge and includes creating the conditions for people to make sense of ideas together, challenge assumptions, connect concepts with experience and learn from perspectives beyond their own.

I have seen moments in programs where a participant's contribution has changed the direction of an entire conversation. It was not written into the facilitator guide, nor could it necessarily have been predicted during the design process, but it connected the concept being explored with the reality of the work people were doing.

Those moments remind me why we should be careful about designing learning experiences so tightly that there is no room left for the learners themselves.

Confidence develops alongside capability

Learning something new requires us to temporarily accept that we do not know everything. For experienced professionals and leaders, that can feel surprisingly uncomfortable. We may be asking people who are highly competent in their roles to practise something unfamiliar, reconsider established habits or talk openly about situations they have not handled particularly well.

A well-designed cohort can make that vulnerability easier because people gradually discover that uncertainty is not unique to them. The manager who thought they were the only person uncomfortable giving feedback may discover that several other leaders experience the same challenge, while another learner may realise that the stakeholder issue they have been struggling with is remarkably similar to something a colleague has already navigated.

That recognition can change the learning dynamic. Questions become easier to ask, experimentation becomes more acceptable and learners can begin to focus less on appearing competent and more on developing their capability.

Of course, psychological safety does not automatically exist because we have called a group a cohort. It needs to be intentionally supported through facilitation, expectations, confidentiality where appropriate, and the way participants respond to one another. When those conditions are present, people can become more willing to explore the difficult parts of learning rather than only displaying what they already know.

The space between sessions is part of the learning

One of the reasons I particularly value cohort-based development is what can happen between formal learning sessions. When a program runs over several weeks or months, learners have an opportunity to take an idea back into their workplace, try it, discover what happens and return to the group with an experience rather than a hypothetical.

Perhaps they try a different approach to a difficult conversation. Maybe they change the way they run a team meeting, practice a coaching technique or deliberately involve a stakeholder earlier than they normally would. When the cohort comes together again, the conversation has changed because participants are no longer only discussing what they learned. They are discussing what happened when they used it. Capability is not demonstrated through understanding alone. Eventually, something needs to happen differently in practice.

A cohort can create a natural rhythm in which people learn something, test it in the reality of their role, return to make sense of that experience with others, refine their thinking and then try again.

For me, this is one of the most valuable elements of cohort learning. The program is no longer confined to the workshop or learning platform because the workplace itself has become part of the learning experience.

From individual learning to collective capability

For HR and L&D leaders, the value of cohorts can extend well beyond individual development. When people from different teams, locations or functions learn together, relationships begin forming across organisational boundaries. Participants gain insight into pressures and perspectives they may not otherwise encounter, and the language introduced through the program can gradually become shared language within the organisation.

This can be particularly useful in leadership development, graduate programs, organisational change, professional development and capability programs where organisations are trying to create greater consistency in how people think, communicate or perform.

Consider the difference between twenty leaders individually completing the same digital module and those twenty leaders spending time discussing how the concepts apply within their organisation, experimenting between sessions and returning to compare what happened. Both approaches may build individual knowledge, but the second also creates an opportunity for people to develop shared understanding, relationships and ways of working.

That begins to move us from individual capability towards collective capability.

For many organisational challenges, particularly those involving leadership, culture, safety and change, we need both.

Cohorts are not the answer to everything

None of this means every learning experience should become a cohort program. Sometimes someone simply needs information, and an accessible digital resource is exactly the right solution. Sometimes personalised learning is more appropriate. Sometimes performance support at the point of need will be far more useful than asking someone to attend a program.

Good learning design is not about choosing between digital, face-to-face, AI-enabled, self-directed, vocational or cohort learning. It begins with understanding what people need to be able to do differently and then designing the most appropriate conditions for that capability to develop.

As learning becomes easier to access individually, I think there is value in being more deliberate about deciding when people should learn together.

Efficiency is one consideration, but the quality of the learning experience deserves equal attention. Some capabilities require conversation, experimentation, disagreement, practice, reflection and the opportunity to hear how another person has approached the same challenge.

Technology can give us extraordinary access to knowledge. It cannot make every learning experience richer simply by making it faster.

Sometimes the people learning beside us become part of how we learn.

So, what you can consider changing

If you are designing or reviewing a learning program, look beyond the content for a moment and consider whether the other learners could become part of the learning experience. Instead of asking only what information needs to be covered, ask what learners need to discuss, practise, retrieve, test and apply together.

Rather than filling every available minute with facilitator-led content, create deliberate space for participants to bring real situations into the room and learn from one another. If the program runs over time, use the intervals intentionally. Give people something meaningful to try in their work, then make the next conversation about what actually happened, including what did not work as expected.

Think carefully about cohort composition as well. A group does not necessarily need to consist of people doing identical jobs. Sometimes the richest learning comes from bringing together people who share a capability need but experience the organisation from very different perspectives.

For those working in VET, there may also be an opportunity to consider how the cohort experience itself can strengthen practice, reflection and peer learning while maintaining the integrity of individual competency assessment.

Most importantly, look beyond attendance, completion and participant satisfaction when evaluating the experience. Consider whether learners are retrieving and applying what they learned, experimenting with new behaviours, continuing to learn from one another and demonstrating the capability the program was intended to develop. If you have read my White Paper on the Capability Illusion, it's a good one to link to this.

Sometimes the strongest contribution we can make as learning professionals is not adding another piece of content. It is creating the environment in which people can genuinely learn, practise and develop alongside others.


Vanessa Trower is the Founder and Principal Consultant of Nexperk, a Sydney-based people and performance partner for large frontline workforces. She hosts The Transformation Edit and SHIFT Happens on the Front Line podcasts. Want to talk about what this could look like in your organisation? Book a chat with Nexperk.

Previous
Previous

Designing for inclusion: small choices that make a difference

Next
Next

Working With Subject Matter Experts Is an EQ Job Wearing a Design Job's Clothes