Crisis Doesn't Build Leaders, It Reveals Them

No leader plans for the week everything goes wrong. But that's the week your people find out exactly who you are, and they never forget it.

The call comes at 6.42 on a Tuesday morning, before coffee, before the day has taken any shape at all. Something has gone wrong. Not the ordinary kind of wrong that gets shrugged off by nine, the network hiccup, the missed delivery. The other kind. The kind where the voice on the other end says the words slowly, because they don't quite believe them either.

For a few seconds, nothing happens. Not because there's no plan. There's always a plan. It lives in a folder called Business Continuity that nobody has opened since the last audit, and today it will do exactly what it was built to do. It will say which regulator gets called first, which statement needs legal's sign-off, which system gets isolated.

What the plan will not do is tell the person holding the phone who they need to be for the next seventy-two hours or longer. Nobody writes that part down. It gets decided, in real time, by the leader they have quietly been becoming for years, usually without knowing this was the interview.

I've spent fifteen years inside organisations, watching this moment land on other people. Enough times now that I can usually predict, within the first few hours, which leaders will still have their team's trust when the dust settles, and which will spend the next two years trying to buy it back. It rarely comes down to intelligence, or even experience. It comes down to something much smaller and much harder to fake.

Crisis doesn't build character. It just switches the lights on and shows everyone what was already there.

Two versions of the same Tuesday

Picture the same incident playing out in two organisations that, on paper, are nearly identical. Same industry, same size, same emergency. Something serious happens on site. People are hurt, thankfully not fatally, but badly enough to close the doors and open an investigation.

In the first organisation, the operational response is close to flawless. The site is secured within the hour. Legal clears a statement before lunch. Insurers are briefed, an incident number issued, every box on the crisis plan ticked in order. Everyone senior does their job, competently, from a safe distance. It takes two full days before anyone with authority walks the floor to speak with the people who watched a teammate carried out on a stretcher. By then the silence has already told its own story, and no update written after the fact undoes what two days of nothing said about who mattered.

In the second organisation, the operational steps look almost identical. Same statement, same insurers, same regulator on the phone by lunchtime. The difference is that within the hour, someone senior is standing on that floor in person, before the statement has even cleared legal, saying the only honest thing available to say. I don't have the full picture yet, and I'm not going to pretend that I do. What I can promise is that I'll be back here, in person, at the end of every day until we do.

Same incident. Roughly the same plan. Nine days later, the first organisation is fielding resignation letters and watching an engagement score that took three years to build quietly fall apart. The second is fielding something else. A workforce that watched their leader show up frightened and honest, and decided that was someone worth staying for.

What gets revealed

Silence is never actually neutral. It feels careful from the inside, like the responsible thing to do before you have full information. From the outside it reads as absence, and people don't fill a vacuum with generosity. They fill it with rumour, fear or their notice period. You don't need every answer to show up. You need to show up, say plainly what you know and what you don't, and tell people exactly when you'll be back with more.

People remember how you made them feel far longer than they remember what you said. Ask anyone six months after a crisis to recite the official statement and they'll struggle. Ask them whether a leader looked them in the eye, whether someone called instead of forwarding an email, and the answer comes instantly. That's the part that becomes the story people tell about your organisation for years.

Your own people are always the second audience, and usually the more attentive one. Every leader under pressure thinks first about the customer, the regulator, the market. Meanwhile the workforce is watching just as closely, drawing quiet conclusions about what kind of organisation they actually work for, based entirely on how leadership treats other people when nobody's making them.

Recovery is a leadership act, not only an operational one. Getting the systems back online and the site rebuilt is operations doing its job well. Rebuilding the belief that leadership will show up again next time, that only happens through ordinary, visible, human behaviour, repeated for weeks after the cameras and the headlines have moved on. Skip that work and you'll fix the building while the trust underneath it stays broken.

Why this is capability work, not just crisis comms

Crisis leadership is too often treated as a communications problem or a legal one, something to be handled by the response team while HR waits for instructions. That's a missed opportunity, and a costly one. The people who understand, better than anyone else in the building, how a frightened workforce needs to be led, are usually already sitting in HR and people roles. Building that capability into leadership development, well before the crisis, not during it, is workforce capability in its purest and most consequential form.

That means rehearsal. Leaders who have only ever considered crisis in the abstract tend to freeze the first time it arrives for real, because the moment feels too large and too unfamiliar to move inside. Leaders who have practised, even through simulation or a well-run tabletop exercise, already know something the others are learning live under pressure. The job in the first hour was never to have the answer. It was to be present, honest about what you don't yet know, and willing to be seen by the people who are scared.

If crisis leadership only ever gets rehearsed in the moment of an actual crisis, the organisation has already decided to leave it to chance.

What actually gets remembered

The six forty two call doesn't ask you to be right. It doesn't ask for a flawless continuity manual, or a statement legal signs off on the first draft. It asks one smaller thing: that you get in the car, or pick up the phone, and let the people who are frightened see that you're frightened too, and that you came anyway.

Years from now, almost nobody in that organisation will remember the wording of the statement, or which regulator got the first call, or how quickly the site was secured. They will remember exactly one thing. Whether you turned up. And that's the uncomfortable part. You don't get to decide that in the moment itself. You already decided it, in every ordinary week that came before this one, whether you realised it at the time or not.


Vanessa Trower is the Founder and Principal Consultant of Nexperk, a Sydney-based people and performance partner for large frontline workforces. She hosts The Transformation Edit and SHIFT Happens on the Front Line podcasts. Want to talk about what this could look like in your organisation? Book a chat with Nexperk.

Previous
Previous

Compliance Training Is Having a Moment.

Next
Next

Better Questions, Better Data: Rethinking Workplace Surveys